Past Masters
- Plymouth Lodge 149
- 1853 – John G. Osborn
- 1854 – John G. Osborn
- 1855 – Greenville P. Cherry
- 1856 – Levi C. Barber
- 1857 – Mark Pomeroy
- 1858 – Mark Pomeroy
- 1859 – John G. Osborn -res
- 1859 – Mark Pomeroy
- 1861 – Martin Rice
- 1862 – Martin Rice
- 1863 – Martin Rice
- 1864 – D. McDonald
- 1865 – J. J. Vinall
- 1866 – J. J. Vinall
- 1867 – J. McDonald
- 1868 – E. R. Shook
- 1869 – J. J. Vinall
- 1870 – H. G. Thayer
- 1871 – H. G. Thayer
- 1872 – Oddver P. Kddnger
- 1873 – Oddver P. Kddnger
- 1874 – H. G. Thayer
- 1875 – John A. Palmer
- 1876 – H. G. Thayer
- 1877 – John F. Langerbaugh
- 1878 – A. L. Reeves
- 1879 – A. L. Reeves
- 1880 – Oddver P. Kddnger
- 1881 – D. L. Dickenson
- 1882 – John C. Jilson
- 1883 – E. M. Forbes
- 1884 – A. L. Reeves
- 1885 – Adam Vinnedge
- 1886 – W. H. Conger
- 1887 – H. Holverson
- 1888 – George H. Thayer
- Kilwinning Lodge 435
- 1871 – Daniel McDonald
- 1872 – Daniel McDonald
- 1873 – Adolphus B. Capron
- 1874 – J. P. Hawkins
- 1875 – J. P. Hawkins
- 1876 – James Houghton
- 1877 – James Houghton
- 1878 – R. A. Chase
- 1879 – David Hull
- 1880 – David Hull
- 1881 – William E. Leonard
- 1882 – Bradley C. Southworth
- 1883 – Wellington E. Bailey
- 1884 – Leander J. Southworth
- 1885 – Joseph Swindell
- 1886 – Sigmund Mayer
- 1887 – William E. Leonard
- 1888 – Daniel McDonald
- Plymouth-Kilwinning Lodge 149
- 1888 – George H. Thayer
- 1889 – John G. Leonard
- 1890 – Charles H. Swindell
- 1891 – William H. Conger
- 1892 – Louis McDonald
- 1893 – Rollo B. Oglesbee
- 1894 – Perry O. Jones
- 1895 – S. C. Loring
- 1896 – Daniel McDonald
- 1897 – Daniel McDonald
- 1898 – Daniel McDonald
- 1899 – William H. Conger
- 1900 – James W. Thayer
- 1901 – D. Frank Redd
- 1902 – Arnott M. Cleveland
- 1903 – Orion F. Hoover
- 1904 – Frank D. Carey
- 1905 – William Everly
- 1906 – C. Oscar Tribbey
- 1907 – George D. Marks
- 1908 – William H. English
- 1909 – Frank S. Southworth
- 1910 – George F. Hitchcock
- 1911 – H. Paul Preston
- 1912 – Charles F. Holtzendorf
- 1913 – Delph L. McKesson
- 1914 – Frank W. Bosworth
- 1915 – Perry J. Troyer
- 1916 – W. H. Lindquist
- 1917 – Alvin Marsh
- 1918 – Francis M. Shepperd
- 1919 – Francis M. Shepperd
- 1920 – Louis E. Steinebach
- 1921 – Rolland B. Metsker
- 1922 – Curtis Haag
- 1923 – Edwin Tanner
- 1924 – Earl Pelkey
- 1925 – Floyd Kebert
- 1926 – George W. Sheller
- 1927 – Charles Pinney
- 1928 – Omer Love
- 1929 – K. Clyde Bennett
- 1930 – Otto Weber
- 1931 – Sewell Falconbury
- 1932 – George F. Stevens
- 1933 – Louis F. Bunnell
- 1934 – Harry Danielson
- 1935 – Earl D. Jacox
- 1936 – Victor Samuelson
- 1937 – Don F. Kitch
- 1938 – Carl E. Burger
- 1939 – Sylvan E. Long
- 1940 – Loren E. Lemert
- 1941 – Clarence W. Myers
- 1942 – Delmas Whitesell
- 1943 – Dewey Redick
- 1944 – Berneth Andrews
- 1945 – Adrian Doran-res.
- 1945 – Clarence W. Myers
- 1946 – Charles E. Evans
- 1947 – B. Leo Helvey
- 1948 – Tom R. Huff
- 1949 – Arthur F. Becknell
- 1950 – James Thain
- 1951 – Walter D. Hampton
- 1952 – George Hollinshead
- 1953 – George H. Davis
- 1954 – Vaughn Dolan
- 1955 – Theodore Zinn
- 1956 – Robert Shaffer
- 1957 – Odis Kennedy
- 1958 – Frank C. Martindale
- 1959 – Dale E. Dolan
- 1960 – Newton E. Tibbetts
- 1961 – Everett E. Miller
- 1962 – Gordon F. Nelson
- 1963 – James E. Yeazel
- 1964 – Fred F. Wolff
- 1965 – Leslie A. Bunn
- 1966 – Lester L. Thomas
- 1967 – V. Stuart Adams
- 1968 – Jack Wilhelm
- 1969 – Haydon Patz
- 1970 – Darl Voreis Jr
- 1971 – Richard Schweisberger
- 1972 – Don J. France
- 1973 – Duane W. Hurford
- 1974 – Melvin Dale Scarberry
- 1975 – James W. Rhoda
- 1976 – George Hammell
- 1977 – James W. Daugherty I
- 1978 – Jack Wilhelm
- 1979 – Robert Daugherty
- 1980 – Harlan Schroeder
- 1981 – Gordon F. Nelson
- 1982 – Dale Scarberry
- 1983 – Robert Daugherty
- 1984 – Robert Zumbaugh
- 1985 – James Barkdull
- 1986 – C. Daniel Shively
- 1987 – Ralph E. Smith
- 1988 – Edwin L. Armes
- 1989 – Eldon D. Shafer
- 1990 – Michael C. Woolfington
- 1991 – Walter L. Carlson
- 1992 – Kennen K. Shafer
- 1993 – John E. Kuhn
- 1994 – Annis E. Crum
- 1995 – Allen E. Reese
- 1996 – Michael E. Pettibone
- 1997 – Eric E. Smith
- 1998 – John K. Kelley
- 1999 – Raymond C. DeVault
- 2000 – David L. Russell
- 2001 – Ty A. Kuhn
- 2002 – James Butler
- 2003 – Gary L. Shaffer
- 2004 – Jim Daugherty II
- 2005 – Jon Van Vactor
- 2006 – Kent Hammonds
- 2007 – Rodney Back
- 2008 – Keith Hammonds
- 2009 – Troy Hartz